Expected shortfall (CVaR)
Expected shortfall is the average loss in the tail beyond VaR. VaR tells you where the bad days start; expected shortfall tells you how bad they are on average.
01The formula
- expected shortfall: the average loss on the days that are worse than VaR
- value at risk at confidence c
- the standard normal density at the quantile z_c
- the size of the tail: for example 2.5% of days
- the standard deviation of the P&L in money over h days
02See it move
03Where it is used
- Risk managerReports expected shortfall alongside VaR, because it reacts to how fat the tail is, not just where it begins.
- Regulators and bank risk teamsBank capital rules for trading books moved from 99% VaR to 97.5% expected shortfall for this reason.
- Quant researcherOptimises portfolios against expected shortfall, which, unlike VaR, never rewards splitting risk into pieces.
04Why traders use it
Two portfolios can have the same VaR while one hides a catastrophic tail. Expected shortfall sees the difference, and it is coherent: the risk of a combined book is never more than the sum of its parts.
05Worked example
A $1,000,000 portfolio with daily volatility 1.5% at 97.5% confidence has a VaR of $29,399 and an expected shortfall of $35,067, so the average tail loss is 1.193 times the VaR. For a normal P&L this ES is close to the 99% VaR of $34,895.
06How it is built
- Start from the VaR point standard deviations, with .
- Average the loss over the tail only: , where .
- The integral of from upwards is , so .
- Since the tail lies beyond VaR, ES is always at least VaR.
07The common mistake
Estimating it from too little data. At 97.5% only one day in forty is in the tail, so a year of history gives about six tail days to average. Expected shortfall from short samples is very noisy.
08In Python and LaTeX
import numpy as np from scipy.stats import norm V, sigma, c, h = 1_000_000, 0.015, 0.975, 1 s = sigma * np.sqrt(h) * V z = norm.ppf(c) print(round(s * norm.pdf(z) / (1 - c)), round(z * s)) # ES and VaR
\text{ES}_c = E\big[\,\text{loss} \mid \text{loss} > \text{VaR}_c\big] = \sigma\sqrt{h}\,V\,\frac{n(z_c)}{1 - c}09Where it fits
Rather not code the maths yourself? Describe your trading idea and let AI build the bot.
Build a bot with AgenKitThe worked example and the model run the same code, so every number matches. Models simplify markets on purpose. This is education, not financial advice.